Tired cabinets make a whole kitchen look worn out. The question is whether to give them a new face or start over. This guide explains what each option changes, when each one makes sense, and how the costs compare, so you can decide before you ask for any estimates.
What Cabinet Refacing Changes
With refacing, the cabinet boxes stay in place. New doors and drawer fronts go on, and a matching veneer or laminate covers the visible frames. Hardware and hinges usually get replaced as part of the job. Our kitchen cabinet refacing page walks through the door styles and finishes.
Refacing works best when:
- The boxes are solid, level, and dry
- You like your current layout
- You want a new look without a long, messy remodel
- You plan to keep your existing countertops
What Cabinet Replacement Changes
Replacement removes the old cabinets and installs new ones. That gives you new boxes, new interiors, and the freedom to change the layout. It also costs more and takes longer, because plumbing, electrical, countertops, and flooring are often affected.
Replacement makes more sense when:
- The boxes have water damage or crumbling particleboard
- Shelves sag or drawers no longer work well
- You want a different layout, an island, or more storage
- You are already planning a larger remodel
How the Costs Compare
Inch Calculator lists a national average of about $7,000 for refacing, and says it often costs about half as much as replacing with custom cabinets. New cabinets run about $100 to $300 per linear foot installed for stock, $150 to $650 for semi-custom, and $500 to $1,200 for custom, according to HomeLight.
These are national figures, not Luxe Kitchen Co. prices. For a full picture of what drives the number, see our kitchen remodel cost guide.
How Long Each Option Takes
Refacing is usually much faster. One contractor guide estimates 3 to 10 days of onsite work once materials arrive. Replacement adds ordering time, and custom cabinets can take several weeks to arrive. Our guide on how long a kitchen remodel takes covers the lead times in more detail.
The Limits of Refacing
Refacing cannot change your layout. It will not move appliances, add tall storage, or resize an island. It also cannot repair problems inside the boxes. If the structure is damaged, a new face will not fix it. A good contractor will tell you this before you spend anything.
A Simple Way to Decide
Answer these three questions:
- Are the cabinet boxes in good condition?
- Do you like your current layout?
- Are you keeping your countertops, or will they be replaced anyway?
If the answer to all three is yes, refacing is likely the better value. If any answer is no, replacement deserves a closer look. If your kitchen dates from the 1990s or 2000s, our post on updating a 1990s or 2000s kitchen explains which parts are usually worth keeping.
Pairing refacing with new counters is a popular choice. Our comparison of quartz, granite, and laminate countertops can help with that decision. And if you are weighing the investment, read whether a kitchen remodel is worth it.
Next Step
The best way to decide is to have someone look at your cabinets in person. We inspect the boxes and give you an honest recommendation in a written estimate.
About the author: Luxe Kitchen Co. is a licensed kitchen remodeling team with 10 years of experience, serving Delaware, Ohio.